Decoding Brock Purdy Hype: Overrated or Deserving?


Brock Purdy has garnered a lot of attention for his performance in the NFL. He received the most votes for the 2024 Pro Bowl Games, totaling 451,864 votes, and was voted the NFC’s highest quarterback vote-getter. Additionally, he has been the subject of MVP discussions most of the season, and the odds are in his favor.

But is this love and respect deserved or is it just one of those one-hit wonders that eventually fades away? Mr. Irrelevant has come a long way according to most fans while some still dispute his experience and accolades. Is Brock Purdy really overrated among football circles, let’s find out.

The Meteoric Rise Of Brock Purdy

Brock Purdy had a successful college career at Iowa State, breaking multiple records and earning numerous accolades. Brock’s impressive college statistics include 4,272 passing yards, 35 total touchdowns, and a 108.9 QB rating.

However, his draft stock fell due to middling results in college leading to his selection in the seventh round of the 2022 draft as the final pick by the San Francisco 49ers, making him “Mr. Irrelevant”.

Since taking over as the 49ers’ starting quarterback, Purdy has thrown 4,280 passing yards, 31 touchdown passes, and a 69.4% completion percentage which have solidified his impact on the gridiron. His leadership qualities are also attributed to his impressive performance and statistics which led to many meaningful victories. His dedication and resilience should be applauded and should inspire the coming generations.

Overrated or Simply Underrated? Separating Fact from Fiction

Is Brock Purdy Overrated

Wherever there are fans there are also critics. Some critics question his arm strength and the ability to consistently make deep throws. They also argue that his success is primarily due to Shanahan’s coaching style and strategy.

However, in comparison to other rookie quarterbacks, Purdy’s statistics and performance have been notable. His impressive statistics have been compared to legendary quarterbacks like Joe Montana.

Purdy’s breakout season is his first as a full-time starter, raising questions about sustainability and lack of experience. Brock is yet to prove himself in the postseason, where pressure intensifies and he hasn’t been able to successfully get a decisive win over other better teams and stronger competition.


Brock Purdy, the San Francisco 49ers quarterback, sparked debates over whether he is overrated. While he has gotten substantial accolades, including leading the NFC in Pro Bowl voting and being considered an MVP contender, there are numerous opinions on the legitimacy of the hype surrounding his career.

While it might still be too early to predict his future success in the football landscape, we can say this with conviction, Brock Purdy is not overrated. The young man is known for his humble lifestyle and perseverance and still has a long way to go to become a Super Bowl champion.

Prikshit Malik
Prikshit Malik
Prikshit is a die-hard basketball fan who has been following the NBA for over a decade. Though he is a Gen-Zer, he likes to consider himself old-school. He is always trying to come up with better arguments for why Michael Jordan is the GOAT, and he will debate anyone on why Kobe and LeBron are a strong second or third. With a passion for sports and his love of writing, he is always excited to see where his words will take him next.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here



More like this

Meet Andy Reid’s Wife, Tammy Reid: A Glimpse Inside the Chiefs HC’s Personal Life

Andy Ried, the head coach of the Kansas City...

Meet George Kittle’s Wife, Claire Kittle: A Look Inside the 49ers TE’s Personal Life

George Kittles, the veteran tight end who plays for...

Christian McCaffrey’s Net Worth (2024): A Look Inside the 49ers RB’s Financials

Christian McCaffrey is a renowned American football player in...

Who Owns the San Francisco 49ers? Exploring the Team’s Ownership Structure

Curious about the owners of the San Francisco 49ers?...